TL;DR
Get audio and creator gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Billy Corgan said on Popcast that he wondered whether Kanye West took inspiration from his approach to fame and controversy. He compared their use of provocation to challenge audiences, but said they had little direct contact and did not claim to know West was influenced by him.
Smashing Pumpkins frontman Billy Corgan said he wonders whether Kanye West drew on his approach to fame, controversy and public debate, during an appearance on Popcast reported by Consequence. Corgan described similarities in how the two artists provoked audiences, but presented the possibility of influence as a question, not a confirmed connection.
The exchange began when Popcast host Jon Caramanica compared Corgan and West, telling the musician, “I hear a lot of Kanye in you.” Corgan replied, “Isn’t it the other way around? Didn’t I come first?” He then recalled that while the Pumpkins were making their 1995 album Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, West was working nearby at a Gap store in Chicago.
Corgan said he did not know West then, though he heard about the rapper’s rise in the city. Looking back, Corgan said he saw a resemblance in the way they approached public attention: “Pick fights, do crazy shit.” He described that tactic as a “cognitive dissonance game”, in which an artist’s provocative behavior prompts people to decide how they regard the work.
He also said he and West have had little direct contact. Corgan described their only conversation as a friendly phone call of about 15 minutes. The interview does not establish that West was aware of Corgan’s approach or that he modeled his own public persona on it.
How Provocation Shapes an Artist’s Image
Corgan’s comments offer a veteran musician’s interpretation of how public controversy can become part of an artistic reputation. His point was not that the two artists made the same work, but that provocation can put audiences and critics in the position of weighing an artist’s behavior against the work itself.
The distinction between a perceived parallel and a documented influence matters. Corgan’s suggestion is personal speculation, and the limited contact he described provides no evidence of a direct exchange of ideas. For readers, the news is the comparison he made on the podcast—not confirmation that West borrowed a strategy from him.
The discussion also comes as the Smashing Pumpkins revisit Mellon Collie through their ongoing Rats in a Cage Tour, which marks the album’s 30th anniversary. That anniversary gives Corgan’s recollections about the period and his place in music history added relevance, while leaving the question of influence unresolved.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
The Mellon Collie Era and Chicago
Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, released in 1995, is the album Corgan referenced when recalling that West was working a block away at the time. Corgan’s account situates the two artists in the same city during an early period in their respective careers, but proximity is not evidence of a relationship. He said he did not know West then.
In the interview, Corgan linked their public personas through a shared willingness to invite arguments about artistic merit. He framed the tactic as a way of making listeners decide whether an artist is a serious creative force or, in his words, an “idiot.” Those remarks describe Corgan’s interpretation of West’s public approach; they do not include a statement from West or independent confirmation of the comparison.
Consequence reported the comments from Corgan’s appearance on Popcast. The supplied report does not provide a full transcript or additional details about the interview beyond the exchange and Corgan’s account of his brief phone call with West.
““When I first saw his game, I thought … was he influenced by the way I did this shit?””
— Billy Corgan, speaking on Popcast
No Evidence of Direct Influence
Whether West was influenced by Corgan remains unknown. Corgan posed the idea as a question and allowed that the similarity could have developed independently, saying “maybe it was just in the water.” The report contains no comment from West addressing the comparison.
Corgan said the pair’s only conversation was a friendly phone call lasting about 15 minutes, but the report does not say when it took place or what they discussed. It also does not provide evidence that West saw Corgan’s actions as a model. The comparison is therefore Corgan’s reading of their public approaches, not a verified account of West’s influences.
Tour Continues as the Album Turns 30
The Smashing Pumpkins’ Rats in a Cage Tour is ongoing and celebrates the 30th anniversary of Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, according to the report. No further details about the tour schedule or any follow-up conversation between Corgan and West were included in the supplied source material.
For now, the immediate development is Corgan’s account on Popcast. Whether West responds to the comparison, or whether additional information emerges about the brief phone call Corgan described, remains to be seen.
Key Questions
What did Billy Corgan say about Kanye West?
Corgan said he wondered whether West had been influenced by his approach to fame and controversy. He compared the two artists’ use of provocation to prompt debate about their work.
Did Corgan say West definitely copied his approach?
No. Corgan raised the possibility as a question and said the similarity might have been “just in the water.” The report does not confirm that West took inspiration from him.
How well do Corgan and West know each other?
Corgan said they had little direct contact and described their only conversation as a friendly phone call lasting about 15 minutes. The report does not say when it happened or what they discussed.
What prompted Corgan’s comments?
Popcast host Jon Caramanica told Corgan, “I hear a lot of Kanye in you.” Corgan responded by recalling the artists’ different career timelines and discussing what he saw as a similar approach to public provocation.
What is the Rats in a Cage Tour?
It is the Smashing Pumpkins’ ongoing tour marking the 30th anniversary of the band’s 1995 album Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, according to the report.
Source: rss
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
